The Creed ArchiveThe Creed Archive
6 min readChapter 1Americas

Origins and Founding

This chapter traces the emergence of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter‑day Saints from its early nineteenth‑century American setting, treating both the tradition's own account of origins and the historical scholarship that situates those claims. It begins with the social and religious environment of upstate New York and western New England during the so‑called Second Great Awakening, a period of intense evangelical revivalism, itinerant preaching, and popular interest in visions and prophecy. That setting — characterized by denominational ferment, competing claims to authority, and heightened expectations of divine activity — provides the immediate cultural context for the events the tradition describes as its founding.

Adherents generally identify a formative visionary experience in the life of Joseph Smith (born 1805 in Sharon, Vermont) as decisive. According to the tradition, a youthful experience commonly dated to 1820, later narrated in multiple accounts, involved Smith's encounter with God the Father and Jesus Christ in a wooded grove near his home in Palmyra/Farmy of western New York. Believers treat this 'First Vision' as the opening act of a restoration: a claim that the Christian church had fallen into doctrinal error and that divine authority and priesthood would be restored through a contemporary prophet. Historians of the period, while recognizing the centrality of these accounts for later believers, document that the First Vision is reported in several versions written at different times (notably accounts written in 1832 and 1838) and they analyze these texts in light of evolving personal memory, sectarian debates, and the journalism and letter writing of the era.

The production and publication of a new scripture is another foundational element. Adherents hold that beginning in 1823 Joseph Smith was visited by an angelic figure named Moroni who revealed the location of buried metal plates inscribed in an ancient language. By 1827 — a date present in traditional narratives — Smith claimed possession of these plates and later worked with scribes to translate them into English. The resulting volume, published as The Book of Mormon in Palmyra, New York, in March 1830, is taken by believers as a second witness of Jesus Christ, an account of ancient peoples in the Americas, and a central textual foundation for the new church. Secular historians approach these claims with questions about sources, provenance, and the literary influences of the early nineteenth century; different scholars offer various explanations for how the text emerged, but most treat the Book of Mormon as a pivotal historical artifact for understanding the movement's identity.

The formal organization of the church is a well‑documented historical event. On April 6, 1830, in Fayette (present‑day Seneca County), New York, a small group of followers organized a body under the name The Church of Christ, a designation that later evolved into the present name. Contemporary records — minutes, affidavits, and early church publications — record the event as an act of formalization: the establishment of a coordinated community with teachings, ordinances, and an expectation of divine guidance. Within a few years the movement attracted converts and outgrew its initial neighborhood, prompting migrations to Ohio (Kirtland), to Missouri, and ultimately to Illinois.

The Kirtland period (roughly 1831–1838) and the Missouri conflicts (1831–1839) provide concrete markers of early institutional development and of violent opposition. In Kirtland, Ohio, the fledgling community built a temple (the Kirtland Temple, construction begun in 1833) and developed financial ventures and missionary endeavors. Missouri became the site of more acute confrontation: settlers and converts clashed with earlier residents over land, local politics, and presumed threats to social order. The Missouri events culminated in 1838 with the issuance of an order by Missouri Governor Lilburn W. Boggs (dated October 27, 1838) that called for the removal of Mormons from several counties — a document historians commonly call the 'Extermination Order' — and in episodes of armed conflict that left deep scars in the collective memory of adherents.

A significant relocation followed. After violent clashes, the community regrouped in and near Nauvoo, Illinois, where leaders built another center of settlement and constructed the Nauvoo Temple beginning in 1841. In Nauvoo Joseph Smith introduced or elaborated several distinctive institutional features — a city council with quasi‑civic powers, new temple ordinances (including the endowment, first administered in 1842), and a rapidly expanding publication program that included a city newspaper. These developments accelerated both internal consolidation and external controversy.

The culminating founding crisis occurred in June 1844. Joseph Smith and his brother Hyrum were arrested and jailed in Carthage, Illinois; on June 27, 1844 both were killed by a mob while being held in Carthage Jail. The deaths are among the best‑attested events in the early record and serve as a decisive turning point: they precipitated immediate questions of succession and led to schisms among competing followers. Different groups claimed legitimate continuity: one followed Brigham Young and the Quorum of the Twelve, eventually migrating west to the Salt Lake Valley; others followed figures such as Joseph Smith III or Sidney Rigdon, producing separate branches and enduring denominational diversity.

The westward migration overseen by Brigham Young in 1846–1847 marks the movement from its eastern roots into the intermountain West. On July 24, 1847, a company under Brigham Young entered the Salt Lake Valley, an event that adherents treat as providential and historians situate within the larger story of frontier settlement, American expansion, and interactions with federal power. In that valley and surrounding regions the community founded new cities, created cooperative institutions, and worked to negotiate relations with the United States government — a long process that included conflict over the practice of plural marriage and eventual capitulation to federal requirements that helped secure Utah's statehood in 1896.

Throughout these episodes the dual strands of devotional narrative and historical analysis remain distinct but interwoven. Adherents narrate the origins as acts of divine restoration centered on prophetic calling and new scripture; scholarship treats those same events as social phenomena embedded in nineteenth‑century American religious culture, migration patterns, and political tensions. Both perspectives illuminate how a small, regionally rooted movement in 1830 grew into a denominational project with global reach.